There has been one thing on my mind lately, particularly this past week, and I don't mean finals. This took full priority of my mind, daydreaming about it for days and counting down the hours until I could say that I experienced it.
The Great Gatsby. I got home from the first showing at my local theatre about twenty minutes ago and I'll be honest, I have not processed it 100%. In fact, I think I may be in shock. The kind of shock that had me so silent after the film that my friends assumed I hated it. No. I definitely didn't hate it.
I will be honest and say that I had high expectations, solely because of Baz Luhrmann, Leo, and Carey. How could the three of them go wrong? But I had read early reviews that had me feeling a bit on edge. And yes, there were things that I didn't love -- but there was a lot that I did. First and foremost: Leonardo as Gatsby. While no one in reality would ever mistake him for being in his 30's, somehow he managed to pull off one of the most young and fresh performances of his career. The happy, in love Gatsby that had me in tears within the first few minutes of him being on screen (and had me in the same state until the very last moment) was incredible. I even bought that he was young; that is, until he had to be dark, broody, a bit mad. But that fit. It all made sense.
And the parties. The visuals were incredible and so true to Luhrmann. The soundtrack was insane, as well, especially the multiple uses of Lana Del Rey's "Young and Beautiful." It truly fit perfectly.
What surprised me the most: Tobey Maguire's portrayal of Nick. Like many of those I spoke to about the film prior to seeing it, I had my doubts about his portrayal of Nick. Yet, I continued saying that it did make sense in a way, if only because he is someone that could step back and allow Gatsby to be the real central character, allow his own character to be forgettable. And I was partially right. There was no question that even though he was the narrator, the person with the most screen time, it is not him that you will walk away rejoicing over. But I was impressed. I never felt like those of us who read the novel and grew to love Nick got jipped. In fact, I think I may like his character even more so now. But that will have to be determined after another re-read.
Things I disliked: A few things, but they were mostly small. I liked the beginnings of Jordan/Nick but hated that they did not follow that true to the novel. However, the Jordan in the film is far more agreeable and interesting than Fitzgerald's version, I think, which could explain why this was left out. Too much Jordan may have taken away from the central love story. I also disliked that the film did not begin with the first words of the novel. I might be picky, but I love when films do this. And finally, I found it incredibly cheesy that Nick pens the words 'The Great' over 'Gatsby' on his manuscript. It was too much. I would have rather had it slipped in as sneaky dialogue.
Things I feel undecided about: Pretty much all of the scenes with Nick in the asylum/therapy sessions. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it either. I found all of that a bit.. well..
eh. The scene where Gatsby is shot and killed; this jarred me completely and I did jump from my seat but I did not burst into open-mouthed sobbed like I thought I would (and kind of hoped I would). While the visuals were lovely, as always, I did not feel any tug to my heart strings. I wasn't overly upset that he had died. Yes, it was somewhat made up for when they showed him in his casket with the voiceovers about how no one came to pay their respects.. but still, no sobs. By then, the tears had dried up. Also, and this is going to hurt me more than it hurts you, but I have to place Carey Mulligan's performance here. I very much liked her as Daisy, but she was never the one that got my feelings going. It was always Leo. I realize this might be because I actually despise Daisy due to reading the novel, but something left me unsure about her portrayal.
Overall, I think I give it an A-/A. I can't quite justify the A, but the A- doesn't give it enough credit. I also have no idea how someone could see that in 2d, when it was so, so incredible in 3d. Something tells me I will take on this experiment in the next few days, though. Once I'm done processing this first watch, of course.